Legal Malpractice Defense
A claim from a former client puts your reputation, your time, and your practice at risk. We accept a limited number of defense engagements for California attorneys and law firms facing legal malpractice and related claims.
Most of our work is on the plaintiff’s side. We know how plaintiff’s counsel builds a malpractice claim, and we use that knowledge to take it apart.
What we handle
- Legal malpractice and breach of fiduciary duty claims
- Defense of attorneys who do not carry malpractice insurance
- Independent (Cumis) counsel when an insurer has reserved its rights
- Pre-litigation demands and tolling agreements
- Fee disputes that turn into malpractice cross-claims
- Malicious prosecution claims against attorneys
- Subpoenas and depositions of attorneys as third-party witnesses
If you have just received a claim
1. Do not respond to the former client yourself. Anything you say can become evidence.
2. Preserve the entire file. Do not alter, add to, or discard anything, including emails and notes.
3. Notify your malpractice carrier promptly. Late notice can put coverage at risk.
4. Call defense counsel early. Many claims can be resolved or narrowed before a lawsuit is filed.
How we approach defense
We evaluate every claim early to set a strategy for resolution. Many cases turn on causation: whether the client would have done any better without the alleged error. We press that issue from the start, through dispositive motions where possible and at trial or arbitration where necessary.
Frequently asked questions
Can you act as my independent counsel if my insurer has reserved its rights? Yes. When an insurer’s reservation of rights creates a conflict of interest, California law may entitle you to independent counsel of your choosing, often called Cumis counsel. Kyle has served in that role.
I do not have malpractice insurance. Can you still represent me? Yes. We frequently represent attorneys who do not carry malpractice insurance. Defense work is billed hourly.
Should I report a potential claim before I am sued? Usually yes. Most policies require notice of circumstances that could lead to a claim. We can help you assess what to report and how.
Is our conversation confidential? Yes. Consultations with attorneys seeking advice about a claim are confidential.